| Platinum | Zapoteca Mexican Grill & Seafood |
| Gold | Moby Dick Restaurant |
| Silver | The Ocean Beach |
| Bronze | Montgomery's Cottage Lunch |
| Top Pick | Coney Island Seafood |
| Top Pick | Fishin' Chips |
| Top Pick | FIVE Kitchen & Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Hooked Fish Bar |
| Top Pick | Tap Restaurant |
| Lighthouse Fresh & Tasty |